Why Charge Customers For Prepaying Loans?

NHB has announced no prepayment penalty for housing loans. I came across the term, Prepayment Penalty while I was working with a Housing Finance company in 2003. I was intrigued and I asked around why there was such a charge.

Here’s the script I used if there was such a question from a customer:

1. Our charges are just 2% while this so-n-so private bank charges 4%. (note: This is not an answer. It’s devised to diverge the question and lead to bashing up the so-n-so bank)

2. There’s this asset liability projections that we have for our loans and these projections go awry if there are prepayments and so we have to charge. (note: this uses heavy jargons and people keep nodding their head without understanding any bit)

3. If the customer is well informed and persistent: Well, I will try to get a waiver from my Regional head and it will take some time. Often it takes more than 15 days.

The effect of this script was that there were hardly any waivers.

The takeaway here is that even though companies are India are not customer friendly, you can get waivers if you are informed and persistent. (Both!)

It’s also good to see regulators cracking the whip on companies to be more customer friendly. I am sure the RBI regulation for banks will come soon. NHB’s regulation applies for housing finance companies alone.

Coming Soon! RupeeCamp "Financial Planning Workshop". "Join us"

Welcome back! Join me on this journey to improving our financial IQ and sharing what we know. Updates at RSS feed or Email. And spread the word please Thank You!

Time To Get Your Credit History

Rajesh was worried when he received a letter from ICICI closing his credit card. Worried, not because he needed the credit card. Worried, because he did not knew that he had that credit card in his name!

Other than being pissed with ICICI for pushing a card down his throat, Rajesh has doubts whether this could impact his credit history.

Rajesh is getting his credit history now and has a detailed post on obtaining credit history from CIBIL. Obtaining credit history costs Rs 142/-

Your credit report gives the loan companies basic information about you, your accounts, and your payment history. In general, it tracks all credit-related activities, although recent activities are given higher weight.

A good credit history can save you thousands/lacs of Rupees in interest charges. How? Well, if you have good credit, it makes you less risky to lenders, meaning they can offer you a better interest rate on loans.

The difference between a 10% loan and a 9% loan for Rs 10 lacs translates to Rs 156710/- over a 20 year period. You may argue that this amount is over a 20 year period and it’s present value would be much less. Yes, but isn’t that a frivolous argument?

I have personal experience of categorizing loanees under three different categories and offering them rates depending on their category. The algorithm that we used was complex, and not very transparent too. With the credit history report available now, the banks are going to use it for sure.

Do get your credit history and take care that you have a good track record. It’s going to pay in future.

Thoughts on Investing in Real Estate in India

A lot of experts advise investing in real estate as an important component of your asset allocation. But I am not really comfortable with this advice for the following reasons.

One, prices are already inflated with the amount of black money invested in this sector.

Two, the dealings in this industry is not really transparent and you are lucky to get a good deal without being an insider.

Three, the increase in value is notional, unless you get hold of another “bigger fool” to buy your real estate.

Four, you need a decent corpus to invest in real estate. Unlike the Rs 500 SIP that you need to invest in a Mutual Fund.

Deepak Parekh makes a few points in his interview in TOI today.
He says,

Basically, I feel the good old days of lowest interest rate are over. At the same time, I’m not concerned that they are going to double up or something. There will be a steady increase, but not a sharp increase. The trend is that interest rates would go up. Maybe, by another 50 basis points or so by December. Again, by another (50 basis points) in the next six months or so. It would have to balance growth and inflation.

Question: Coming to the realty sector, do you think affordable housing is going to be a reality in the country?

Deepak Parekh: Unfortunately for affordable housing, the bigger problems are in Delhi and Bombay. In these two cities land prices have shot through the roof. Unless the government is willing to give some land or develop some land for affordable housing, I don’t see how prices can come down significantly.

One of the complex things in India is to buy an apartment and not get cheated.

I’m sure a lot of you will disagree. I’m waiting to hear from you!

Home Loan Teaser Rates

While there’s a race for grabbing a large share of the home loan market through ‘teaser’ rates by banks, the government today warned that such schemes could land borrowers in financial distress.

“…Borrowers with low financial means may get attracted to take such loans on finding the initial low interest rates to be within their financial means, but may land themselves into a financial distress should interest rates start rising…,” Minister of state for Finance Namo Narain Meena told the Lok Sabha.

The caution was voiced by Meena at a time when the two leading private lenders -HDFC Ltd and ICICI Bank -relaunched teaser rates, offering loans at an interest rate of 8.25 per cent for the first year, followed by 9 per cent in the next and the market rate thereafter.

India’s largest lender SBI is already continuing with a similar scheme.

Commenting on the implication of such concessional interest rate loans, Minister of state for Finance Namo Narain Meena said the resulting delinquency would have adverse impact on the financial stability of the lending banks.

India’s banking regulator -the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) had also expressed concern on banks offering home loans with teaser rates, or schemes where monthly instalments rise after the initial years.

“Teaser rates are increasingly being offered which is a cause for concern,” said Usha Thorat, deputy governor, RBI had said. PTI ICICI Bank relaunches cheap home loans Country’s largest private sector lender ICICI Bank has re-launched its special home loan plan, also called teaser rates, to attract property buyers. “Mortgages continue to be a focus area for ICICI Bank. We offer competitive rates in the market and currently the rates are 8.25 per cent for first year, 9 per cent for the second year and the existing floating rate thereafter,” said a spokesperson of ICICI Bank.

The two other major financial institutions which are offering teaser rates are State Bank of India and HDFC.

Does the teaser rates worry you or it worries you that the Govt. is interfering ?

How I Made Rs 1,27,535 in One Day!

Okay, that looks like a scam. Well, it’s a header bait. But actually, I saved myself that amount of money by making an informed decision about my home loan.

Along the process of making an informed decision on my home loan, I learnt that paying 10% rate of interest is better than paying 8.75%. It’s a pretty unique situation of mine that makes it TRUE!!

How? Let me share you my story. But before I begin, a big Thanks to BankBazaar. Because the story starts and ends with them. On BankBazaar.com, you can get instant customized quotes for loans and easily compare the total costs of the loan offers made to you.

Let me share my home loan details. I took a loan of Rs 10 lacs in August, 2004. The starting rate of interest (ROI) was 7.25%. After going to a peak ROI of 11%, it has now come down to 10.25%.

The starting EMI was just Rs 7900.00 but as the rates skyrocketed, the EMI was raised to Rs 8951.00.

I have prepaid an amount of Rs 3 lacs from time to time. As on date, the outstanding principal balance is Rs 6.20 lacs. In other words, the outstanding balance would have been Rs 9.20 lacs if I had not prepaid Rs 3 lacs.

That also means that for the last 5 years when I have paid over Rs 5 lacs in EMI, the actual Principal that has been repaid is just Rs 80,000!! (Phew, the EMI principle is so skewed in favour of lenders!)

Anyway, let’s come back to my home loan story. The banks are beginning to advertise attractive rates for new home loans with some hovering around 9% ROI. And when I checked with my own home loan ROI, they said it’s still 11% and will be reduced to 10.25% from August, 09 onwards.

It was time, I thought, to look around for a better home loan and get my loan transferred to a better rate.

I knew about BankBazaar. It’s a very powerful engine to search for the best quotes on loans. In a few minutes, I figured out a quote which looked very attractive. I was offered 8.75%.

The support functions at BankBazaar worked really well and within a few hours I got the phone call from the Bank offering 8.75%. They offered to collect the documents from me. The document required were already specified in the BankBazaar process and they added a foreclosure letter to be obtained from my existing lender.

While getting the foreclosure letter from my existing lender, I also asked for the amortization schedule for my loan. This amortization schedule tells you the portion of interest and principal in your EMI and tells you the reducing balance principal after every EMI payment. You also get to know how long it will take to repay the loan. Check this Loan Amortization Schedule

Now I saw that the total number of EMI payable is just 110. So the loan will be repaid in roughly 9 years. The total interest portion that has to be paid is Rs 3.66 lacs. (A)

On doing a similar exercise for my new loan offer @8.75% for 14 years, the total interest payout is Rs 4.75 lacs. Add the prepayment charge of 2% to be paid to the old lender and 1% processing fee to the new lender, the total interest and fee works out to Rs 4.94 lacs. (B)

The difference between these two scenarios (A & B) is Rs 1,27,535.00!!

So even though I get an offer @8.75% instead of the 10.25%, my total interest/fee cost is less than the lesser offer!

Learnings:
Surprising? Not if you figure out that the enhanced EMI is enabling me to make a part prepayment every time I pay an EMI. So even though I had taken a loan for 20 years, the enhanced EMI is helping me prepay the loan in just 14 years!

Another learning is that it is important to consider the repayment term of your loan. If I go in for a loan @8.75% for 11 years, the difference in interest/fee would be negligible. For less than 11 years, I will make some savings by transferring the loan.

Check out BankBazaar’s powerful Refinance calculator

Do you have anything to share about your home loan? Or do you have any questions? The comments section is awaiting your response.